The Shure V15 Type III and Shure V15 Type IV are both legendary phono cartridges, each with its own unique characteristics and capabilities. These cartridges have left an indelible mark on the world of analog audio and are celebrated for their precision tracking, exceptional sound quality, and enduring appeal. In this comprehensive comparison, we will dissect the similarities, differences, and key attributes of the Shure V15 Type III and Shure V15 Type IV, helping you determine which one might be the ideal choice for your vinyl listening experience.
Shure V15 Type III: A Classic Icon
The Shure V15 Type III is a classic among phono cartridges, known for its remarkable tracking ability, clean sound, and detailed audio reproduction. It has been a favorite among vinyl enthusiasts for decades and is celebrated for its precision and reliability.
Shure V15 Type IV: Pushing the Boundaries
The Shure V15 Type IV, introduced as an evolution of its predecessor, aimed to push the boundaries of what a phono cartridge could achieve. It features advanced technologies and improvements over the Type III, offering enhanced performance and a more comprehensive design.
Key Specifications
Before we delve into the comparison, let’s examine the key specifications of these cartridges:
Shure V15 Type III:
- Stylus Shape: Hyperelliptical
- Tracking Force: 0.75 – 1.5 grams
- Output Voltage: 3.5 mV
- Frequency Response: 15 Hz – 25 kHz
- Cantilever Material: Beryllium
- Compliance: Medium
Shure V15 Type IV:
- Stylus Shape: Micro-Ridge
- Tracking Force: 1.25 – 2.0 grams
- Output Voltage: 3.5 mV
- Frequency Response: 15 Hz – 27 kHz
- Cantilever Material: Beryllium
- Compliance: Medium
Comparison: Shure V15 Type III vs. Shure V15 Type IV
Now, let’s explore a comprehensive comparison between the Shure V15 Type III and Shure V15 Type IV across various aspects:
- Design and Build:
- The V15 Type III features a hyperelliptical stylus, while the V15 Type IV boasts a Micro-Ridge stylus. The Micro-Ridge stylus profile is known for its precision and tracking ability.
- Both cartridges utilize a beryllium cantilever, prized for its rigidity and lightweight construction.
- Sound Quality:
- Both cartridges offer exceptional sound quality, characterized by precise tracking, detail retrieval, and clean sound.
- The V15 Type IV is known for pushing the limits of high-frequency response, resulting in slightly crisper treble notes.
- Tracking Ability:
- Both cartridges excel in tracking ability, minimizing distortion and wear on your vinyl records.
- The V15 Type IV offers a slightly higher tracking force range, which can be advantageous for those seeking precision and control.
- Output Voltage:
- Both cartridges share a similar output voltage of 3.5 mV, suitable for most phono stages and preamps.
- Frequency Response:
- The V15 Type IV extends the frequency response up to 27 kHz, potentially capturing even more audio detail in high-frequency passages.
- Compliance:
- Both cartridges have medium compliance, ensuring compatibility with a wide range of tonearms and turntables.
Legacy and Collectibility:
- Both the Shure V15 Type III and V15 Type IV have achieved legendary status, making them sought-after collector’s items in the vintage audio market.
- Prices for these cartridges can vary widely in the used and vintage market, influenced by condition, rarity, and collector demand.
Conclusion
The choice between the Shure V15 Type III and Shure V15 Type IV comes down to your personal preference, system compatibility, and your priorities in audio playback. While the Type III is a classic icon celebrated for its reliability and performance, the Type IV represents an evolution in design and high-frequency response.
Both cartridges offer a compelling vinyl listening experience, with precise tracking and detailed sound reproduction. Whether you’re seeking the enduring charm of the Type III or the enhanced capabilities of the Type IV, you’re embarking on a journey of high-fidelity vinyl playback, experiencing the legacy of two giants in the world of analog audio.