Drummers often wonder if they can interchange the batter head and the resonant head on their drums. While the two heads serve different purposes and have distinct characteristics, some drummers may consider using a batter head as a resonant head or vice versa. In this article, we will explore the possibilities and implications of using a batter head as a resonant head and discuss the factors to consider before making this decision.
Understanding the Differences: Before diving into whether it’s feasible to use a batter head as a resonant head, it’s important to understand the differences between these two types of drum heads.
- Construction and Design: Batter heads are typically designed to withstand the impact of drumstick strikes and produce the primary sound and attack of the drum. They are usually reinforced and have a coating or laminate for added durability. On the other hand, resonant heads are designed to enhance the drum’s tone, sustain, and resonance. They are often thinner and more responsive to vibrations.
- Tone and Sound: Batter heads are responsible for producing the fundamental tone and attack of the drum, while resonant heads contribute to the drum’s sustain, depth, and overall resonance. These distinct roles make each head suited for its specific function in creating the desired drum sound.
Can a Batter Head Be Used as a Resonant Head? Technically, it is possible to use a batter head as a resonant head, but there are several factors to consider before doing so:
- Sound and Tonal Characteristics: Batter heads are designed to provide a focused attack and projection, whereas resonant heads are intended to enhance the drum’s sustain and depth. Using a batter head as a resonant head may result in a different tone and overall sound, potentially affecting the drum’s desired characteristics.
- Thickness and Response: Resonant heads are typically thinner and more responsive to vibrations. Batter heads, being constructed with added durability and reinforcement, may not offer the same level of responsiveness when used as resonant heads. This could potentially affect the drum’s overall resonance and tonal qualities.
- Tuning and Balance: Tuning the batter head and the resonant head separately allows drummers to achieve the desired pitch separation and balance. Using a batter head as a resonant head might make it challenging to fine-tune each head independently, potentially compromising the drum’s overall sound and response.
- Durability and Wear: Batter heads are designed to withstand the impact of drumstick strikes, which means they are built with added durability. Using a batter head as a resonant head may result in quicker wear and potential damage due to the thinner construction and different purpose for which resonant heads are designed.
While it is technically possible to use a batter head as a resonant head, it is not recommended due to the distinct characteristics and purposes of these two types of drum heads. Batter heads and resonant heads are designed to work together to create a balanced and desired drum sound. Interchanging them may result in an altered tone, compromised tuning capabilities, and potential durability issues. It is advisable to use the appropriate head for its intended purpose to achieve optimal sound quality, sustain, resonance, and overall drum performance.
