Vinyl collectors love surprises—rare pressings, unusual variants, first editions, and factory oddities. One curiosity that often sparks excitement is a mislabeled record, where one side carries the wrong label. But the big question is: Does this mistake actually make your vinyl more valuable?
Let’s break it down.
What Is a Mislabeled Record?
A mislabeled record occurs when the paper label applied during manufacturing doesn’t match the audio pressed into that side. For example:
- Side A label appears on both sides
- A completely different album’s label is used
- Incorrect track listing
- Wrong pressing plant label or color variant label
These mistakes usually happen during the final stages of production, and they typically slip past quality control.
Is a Mislabeled Record Rare?
Yes… and no.
Mislabeled records aren’t extremely common, but they’re also not unheard of—especially in older pressings or budget label releases. Many pressing plants in the ’60s–’90s had looser QC, so label mix-ups happened more frequently.
However, rarity does not automatically equal value.
Does a Wrong Label Make Your Vinyl Worth More?
Sometimes—but only under certain conditions.
The value of a mislabeled record depends heavily on:
1. Artist Popularity
If the record is from a highly collectible artist (e.g., Beatles, Pink Floyd, Nirvana), even minor manufacturing quirks can be desirable.
2. Demand for the Error
Some errors become cult collectibles. Others are just considered factory flaws.
Collectors value:
- Label printed with wrong album information
- Label from a completely different artist
- Famous misprints that are documented in collector communities
They don’t value:
- Generic label duplication (“Side A” on both sides)
- Misspelled track names
- Low-demand artists or mass-market albums
3. Condition Still Matters Most
Even rare misprints drop significantly in value if the vinyl is:
- Scratched
- Warped
- Shows ring wear
- Is covered in mold or moisture damage
4. Whether the Error Is Documented
Some misprints become widely recognized, boosting collectability. For example:
- The 1965 Beatles Rubber Soul label error
- Certain U.S. Led Zeppelin IV label variants
If your misprint isn’t documented, it may be interesting—but may not command a premium.
How Much More Can It Be Worth?
There is no fixed rule, but as a general guideline:
- Low-demand record with misprint
→ No real added value - Mid-tier artist with unusual mislabel
→ 5–20% increase - Major artist with well-known misprint
→ 50%+ increase - Legendary artists with documented, sought-after misprints
→ Can be 2x to 10x the normal price
Again, condition and demand are everything.
How to Check If Your Mislabeled Record Is Valuable
Here’s what to do:
✔ Search Discogs for your release
Look under the “Notes” section for mentions of:
- mislabeled copies
- variant labels
- known misprints
✔ See if other collectors are discussing it online
Try forums like:
- Steve Hoffman
- Vinyl Collective
- Reddit r/vinyl
✔ Compare sale prices of similar misprints
A rare misprint is only valuable if someone actually wants it.
Should You Sell It or Keep It?
Keep it if:
- You love unique or “quirky” vinyl
- The misprint interests you personally
- It doesn’t affect play
Sell it if:
- You confirm demand
- It’s a collectible artist
- Condition is excellent
Final Verdict: Is It Worth More?
A wrong label can make a vinyl worth more, but only when collectors actively seek that specific misprint.
For many records, it’s simply a fun manufacturing error—not a major price booster.
If your mislabeled record is from a big-name artist and the mistake is notable, you may have something truly collectible on your hands.