Shure is a renowned name in the world of audio equipment, and its V15 series of phono cartridges has achieved legendary status among audiophiles and vinyl enthusiasts. The Shure V15 II and Shure V15 III are two highly regarded cartridges known for their exceptional performance. In this comprehensive comparison, we will dissect the differences and similarities between these two iconic phono cartridges, helping you decide which one might be the right fit for your vinyl listening experience.
Shure V15 II: A Classic
The Shure V15 II, released in the late 1970s, is a classic phono cartridge that has stood the test of time. It is known for its excellent tracking ability, detail retrieval, and clean sound.
Shure V15 III: An Evolution
The Shure V15 III is the successor to the V15 II and was introduced in the early 1980s. It builds upon the strengths of its predecessor and incorporates advancements in cartridge design and materials.
Key Specifications
Before we dive into the comparison, let’s look at the key specifications of these cartridges:
Shure V15 II:
- Stylus Shape: Hyperelliptical
- Tracking Force: 0.75 – 1.5 grams
- Output Voltage: 3.5 mV
- Frequency Response: 15 Hz – 25 kHz
- Cantilever Material: Beryllium
- Compliance: Medium
- Stylus Replacement: SAS (Super Analogue Stylus) available
Shure V15 III:
- Stylus Shape: Hyperelliptical
- Tracking Force: 0.75 – 1.5 grams
- Output Voltage: 3.5 mV
- Frequency Response: 15 Hz – 25 kHz
- Cantilever Material: Beryllium
- Compliance: Medium
- Stylus Replacement: JICO replacement styli available
Comparison: Shure V15 II vs. Shure V15 III
Now, let’s delve into a comprehensive comparison between the Shure V15 II and Shure V15 III based on various aspects:
- Design and Build:
- Both cartridges feature a similar design with a hyperelliptical stylus and beryllium cantilever.
- The V15 III is slightly updated in appearance but retains the classic Shure look.
- Sound Quality:
- Both cartridges are praised for their clean and detailed sound.
- The V15 III is often considered a slight improvement over the V15 II in terms of high-frequency response and tracking ability.
- Tracking Ability:
- Both cartridges offer excellent tracking, making them suitable for a wide range of vinyl records.
- The V15 III incorporates minor improvements that enhance tracking and reduce distortion, especially in high-frequency passages.
- Stylus Replacement:
- The V15 II can be upgraded with a Super Analogue Stylus (SAS) for improved performance.
- The V15 III can be fitted with JICO replacement styli, providing options for stylus replacement.
- Availability and Pricing:
- Both cartridges are discontinued by Shure, making them collectible items.
- Prices for these cartridges can vary widely in the used and vintage market, depending on condition and rarity.
- Legacy:
- The V15 II and V15 III have cemented their place in audio history as legendary cartridges appreciated for their sonic qualities.
Conclusion
The Shure V15 II and Shure V15 III are both exceptional phono cartridges that have left an indelible mark on the world of analog audio. While the V15 III represents an evolution of the V15 II with slight improvements in tracking and high-frequency response, both cartridges are highly regarded for their clean and detailed sound.
Ultimately, the choice between these two cartridges may come down to personal preference, availability, and your specific turntable setup. Whichever one you choose, you’ll be experiencing the legacy of Shure’s commitment to high-quality audio reproduction in the world of vinyl records.
